Sabrinas Pizza & Restaurant, 1641 S Olden Ave, Hamilton, NJ
Su-Th 10 AM - 10 PM; F-Sa 10 AM - 11 PM
(609) 888-1299 Website Google Maps
Though located in an out-of-the-way Hamilton strip mall, Sabrina’s is a surprisingly pleasant place to eat a pie. Yes, it’s a standard pizza storefront. But the furniture is new and comfortable, the service is competent, and it’s immaculately clean. And what a pie! The crust is flavorful and chewy. It started crispy all the way to the center, and while it softened (particularly under the fresh mushrooms) it stayed firm to the end. Good cheese and tomato. Personally, I found the tomato a little heavy on the basil, but most people enjoy that flavor more than I do. Definitely one of the best tomato pies around.
Semi-Finalists: Anthony's IV Pizza Cafe Antonio Candela Pizzeria & Ristorante Corleone's Old Fashion Tomato Pie DeLorenzo's Pizza Mamma Flora's Mamma Rosa's Original Dominick's Pizza Palermo's Palermo's of Hamilton Pete's Steak House Sportsmen's Pub Two Brothers Trattoria (Capital Center)